Saturday, May 21, 2011

Wk3 Comment #2 to Holly Loganbill


Holly wrote:
“A transformation is a shift in how we experience the world, and these shifts happen continually, often just beyond our notice.”

Just as before, there’s just so much in the Zanders’ writing. The idea of “white sheets” to give the orchestra members an opportunity to comment and contribute is just brilliant and so very humble. I don’t remember often enough to invite students up to present or teach, but I’m noticing their potentials now.

“Don’t take yourself so (darn) seriously.”

The observations by Roz Zander about family dynamics really hit home. As the oldest of five children in a very dysfunctional family, I found them so enlightening.

“A child comes to think of himself as the personality he gets recognition for or, in other words, as the set of patterns of action and habits of thought that get him out of childhood in one piece.”

We really do take on those coping personalities, and they really stick. It’s hard to shake them. That’s one more way that the Zanders are affecting my view of students. It’s hard to remember sometimes that they have a life outside school that has shaped them; they haven’t chosen their challenges.

“It is important to realize that ‘good’ and ‘bad’ are categories we impose on the world—they are not of the world itself.”

Clearing shoulds, closing exits, and clearing judgments are all difficult. It’s so much easier to avoid dealing with feelings, particularly with all the ways we have of distracting ourselves these days. The downward spiral talk really stood out for me. It’s something you hear a lot at our school, and it leaves no room for hope or possibility.

“Shine attention on obstacles and problems and they multiply lavishly.”

You really do get more of what you focus on, and the example of buying a car and suddenly seeing them everywhere is so perfect. It’s so easy to begin listing all the reasons why you can’t do something, like learn new technology; there’s not enough time, what if something goes wrong, and there’s so much other work to do are just a few of the reasons I hear for postponing or avoiding integrating new digital tools.

“Speaking in possibility springs from the appreciation that what we say creates a reality; how we define things sets a framework for life to unfold.”

How much more productive would it be to be looking for openings in the schedule rather than imagining all the things that could go wrong and keep one from even getting started.

“…performance is not about getting your act together, but about opening up to the energy of the audience and of the music, and letting it sing in your unique voice.”

As I walk to the digital projector and SMART Board these days, it’s becoming easier and easier to tap into the curiosity and energy of the students. The Zanders have really impacted my awareness. I don’t have the students all day, only two or three hours a week, and I often don’t get to know them very well. Lately I’ve noticed that I don’t have to “know” them in order to engage them and tap into that curiosity. In all the scheduling and other duties of the day, I’d really lost the sense of excitement and enthusiasm about what I’m sharing with them. It needs to be more fun. That leads to the final thought from the reading,  “Participate!”

image by
modified by Jana Claybrook 
Holly,
Zander’s white sheets also intrigued me.  After reading your post I was reminded of a saying I used at our new teacher in-service.
“Teach like it’s Christmas” by Professor Joe Martin
·      We are not just teachers. We are paid to unwrap OTHER people’s gifts.
·      Parents have wrapped their gifts (children) as beautifully as they possibly could, and they’ve chosen to share their gifts with you and me.
·      However, one thing to be aware of…. DON’T judge the gifts in your class by the wrapping paper.
·      Their parents are sending us the best gifts they have.
·      Be sensitive enough to know that some gifts are wrapped tightly, been mishandled, discarded, been returned, and even arrive “special delivery. They are still gifts to be treasured and appreciated.
We must remember the “silent conductor”. A leader can be hiding inside the most unlikely student.

Wk3 Comment #1 to Leah Frye


Leah wrote:
Conducting from any chair was a wonderful chapter illustrating from both a leader’s and a contributor’s point of view. My thoughts drifted by all the “chairs” I have taught from and the effectiveness of each. Just for starters, next year I’ll have students running the controls at my computer when I am engaging the class using the screen or the smart board.
RULE #6- “There aren’t any [more]” I heard myself laughing again. This chapter is all about the power of humor and lightening-up. As I read, I wrote down so many ideas but I’ll only share this one memory:
My Little Man (LM as we call him) and his friend Lucas were having a wonderful afternoon playing. They spent most of the time over here then decided to go across the street to Lucas’ house. I watched them walk over, noticed some rogue dandelions and began pulling a few out. Suddenly, from across the street came the “f” word repeated several times and the slam of a car door. The next thing I knew, a very heated argument erupted between two men in Lucas’ driveway. The “f “ word was being used for every part of speech. I just sent my son over there!! Without any more thought, I marched over. With one hand waving a finger, and the other holding up my long skirt so as not to trip, I walked between the two announcing, “Gentlemen! I am getting the boys. You can continue this once we are gone!” They both just kind of stood in place with their mouths open for a few moments, then continued the barrage of nastiness.
Both boys were scared and crying as we walked back to our place. They were still pretty tense for a bit going on about what had happened. I explained that sometimes adults say things they wouldn’t normally say when they are angry. But that didn’t really help. To lighten things up I did something that LM and me do quite often when I want to engage him in play. I walked up to LM, finger pointing, eyebrows down, eyes squinting, saying, “Yooou….Yooou!” I usually tickle him with the out stretched finger, but I didn’t have a chance this time. He returned the act with the same expression, pointing his little finger saying, “Yoooou….Yoooouu…….Boogerface!” I turned to Lucas who was sitting in the couch behind me and looking more worried then ever.
I asked, “ Did you just hear what he called me??”
Wide eyed and fingers in his mouth he said, “yes….”
“He called me a boogerface!? Who calls someone else a boogerface??” Lucas’ now confused expression 


suddenly sprang into a giggling smile, “…boogerface.” he whispered as LM giggled from behind me. Within minutes, they were back to the business of playing, laughing, and enjoying each other’s company.

The way things are. I mentioned in wimba the other night about how I sometimes feel like I’m thinking like a spoiled teenager, rolling my eyes (in my head ofcourse) as I try to deal with an administration with a lack of warmth and sunshine. As a matter of fact they have rained on many of our parades over the last couple years. Although I still wait for the next criticism to come (“how fascinating” I’d love to say), I am starting to relax and really focus more on my students. How can I help my students be their best, learn and enjoy my class, instead of changing who I am and my love for teaching only to please a few.

The best way for me to describe giving away to passion is something that I have felt guilt over. A good teacher has all in place and sticks with the lesson from start to finish. This has always been my belief. However, I am guilty of going with the flow of the lesson. If in the middle of creating I have a new idea of how the students my benefit more from the lesson, then I will change that part right then and there. If the students find personal connections, I let as many as I can speak before we move on. This has meant that my lesson maps are often off by a few weeks by the end of the year. 


image by
jontintinjordan's photostream
Leah,
After I read chapter 5 I too began drifting back to all the “chairs” and reliving the faces of former students. Did I overlook a potential leader? Well, I can’t go back but I can look forward and keep the mindset that I gained from the “Art of Possibility”.



image by

CarbonNYC's photostream



Thanks for sharing the story about Little Man I would have loved to see the men’s faces when you walked between them. (Priceless)  As a cheer coach I must use RULE #6 daily. Whether dealing with drama between my squad members or their parents I must remember not to take things so serious.
I agree humor can help diffuse a potential touchy situation.   

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Wk3 Reading: Art of Possibility Chapters 5-8

My major highlight in this week’s reading was the question from chapter:
How much greatness are we willing to grant people? 
I think this is a valid point whether working with colleagues or students. 
Are we willing to pass the baton?


image by 

tableatny's photostream


Passing the baton in your classroom could mean changing your instruction from teacher given to student driven. The “sage on the stage” disappears and the self-directed learning takes its place. Imagine using Ben Zander’s technique of the “silent conductor” within your own classroom. I wonder what my own students would say if given the chance and called upon to lead. 

I’m sort of in a leadership position at my school district and reading the stories from students made me rethink my leadership style. I must remember the point Amanda made about leadership not being a responsibility but in fact a shining gift. I think I got so comfortable leading that I forgot to shine. 

I know I keep going on about his “white sheet” stories but they made such an impression on me. My Middle School is about to begin the “Leader in Me” program based on Stephen R. Covey's 7 Habits and as I read this book I can’t help thinking about our endless possibilities.

Saturday, May 14, 2011

Wk2 Free Post

 Wimba 5-9-11
Image by PhotoMasterGreg


Wimba was very interesting comparing copyright to trademark and patent laws. It made me think about what actually could be copyrighted.
 
The 10 myths hit very close to home and I have heard these several times throughout my teaching career. 
                       
 Fair Use   
Enhancing a lesson with only using a small portion and not the whole piece is stillbreaking Fair Use.
 
If you cannot teach the unit without including the media, then it might qualify for Fair Use.
The YouTube scenario really made a lot of sense. YouTube sends the viewer back to the original artists site to help ensure the credit is given to the appropriate individual. 

Wk2 Comment #2 to Peter Binskin


Peter wrote:
The Art of Possibility by Rosamund Stone Zander and Benjamin Zander (2000) is a great book to read! I think that having us watch the TED video of Benjamin Zander first was a great idea because it puts much of the book in perspective and gives the book a voice (I couldn’t get that joyful British voice out of my head as I read it). It really is a book of stories on changing perspectives and finding the joy of living in everything. It also asks us to look at a broader world of opportunities, not for what we can gain personally, but what we can gain by giving ourselves to those in our field of influence.
As a teacher the Michelangelo analogy was very strong for me. Do I see my students as infinite potential or am I just there to deliver the curriculum and compare them to other students? It’s a hard thing to rejoice in an individual’s abilities when the parents too are asking how are they doing compared to the rest of the class or the state. This measurement world is very strong and is continually being used as justification and blame on those who do not measure up and those who are charged with the job of raising people up to those invented standards. I have to admit that I myself have been focusing on measurements throughout this course and get stressed at each activity, wondering if I have done what is required to satisfy the course requirements rather than being a contribution to those around me in my academic community, both inside and outside the course.
One thing I can say is that I am quite energized by this book and I hope I can find a way to let myself give up my measurement driven way of thinking to something more uplifting. I’m enjoying this book so much that I am recommending my wife read it to give her tools to help with managing people at her work.

Peter,
I also liked watching the TED video before reading the book.  Interesting perspective you have on measurement, I liked how you related it to the teaching profession. As I have gotten to know you this year I find it hard to believe you are just a deliverer of the curriculum. (Look at the President’s song) I believe you will help your students’ to find their infinite potential and chip away any obstacles they may face to reach it.

Wk2 Comment #1 to Heather Anderson

Heather wrote:
The Amazing Power of "A"
I have never liked grades even though I have always strived to get straight A's or high scores of some sort. Grades and scores on tests never really seem to describe my potential as a student or a person. I could get 100% in a class and feel like I have learned nothing. I could also try really hard and spend countless hours on a spanish essay, yet only recieve a B, because the teacher didn't believe I was capable of every achieving an A. Needless to say, I didn't always try my hardest to achieve the grades, but I always expected good grades.

After reading the third chapter in the Art of Possibilty, I reviewed my perspective of both giving and receiving grades. If there was no struggle to worry about the grade and the outcome in the end, would the student apply herself more during each lesson? Would she worry more about what she is learning rather than what label she is going to receive at the end of the course? I thought about my experiences throughout all of my education. Through high school, it was only about the grade, I don't remember what I learned or why teachers chose to teach us certain material. But in college, I started to pay attention to my learning more. I found myself enjoying studying the material and I could actually remembered what I learned! I stopped caring about the grades. But with this new found love and enjoyment of learning, the high scores and A grades came naturally.

I love the idea of giving everyone an A at the beginning of the course or class. It tells the students that you believe in them and you believe in their successes as students and people. I would love to try this with my students, however my students are still very young and haven't had much exposure to grades, so they don't quite understand the pressure yet. I think I will try it with an older grade at some point to see how they act differently.

We should get rid of grades altogether, but unfortunately states think that numbers and grades are what defines a school and it's students. If that frame of thinking were to change, then I think everyone would be more successful regardless of who they are or what they are studying!




Heather,
I agree giving everyone an A at the beginning would certainly convey the belief you have in your students’ success. Isn’t it funny how reading something can throw you back in time and have you relive an experience with a teacher. (Good or Bad)
Image from Creative Commons
moonstarsandpaper.blogspot.com


That is why as educators we must take a hard look in the mirror. What other profession has such an impact on the lives of others?
 

Wk2 Reading: Art of Possibility


Is your Cup Half Full or Half Empty?
Image from Creative Commons
By Jesiehart's Photostream

After reading the first four chapters in the Art of Possibility, I began thinking about my personal story and my survival thinking. I use the personal motto, “attitude is contagious” and try hard each and every day to live it.  Although, people try hard to crush my spirit I don’t let them defeat my positive outlook. 

 The reading shared the story of the shoe factory with one marketing scout seeing the negative “no one wears shoes” and the other seeing the positive  “they have no shoes”.  Which describes you? I tend to look for the positives in any given situation.

As a teacher, I am constantly looking for the positive and potential in my students. It wasn’t until I read chapter 3 and the Michelangelo quote that it truly became clear. We must chip away the obstacles that tend to get in the way of each child’s developing to their fullest potential. Using the practice of “Giving an A” could transform attitudes and open the universe of possibility for even our students. 

As I reflected on this chapter, I wonder what grade my students would give me?

It really made me reflect on my own teaching and even my personal relationships. Revealing I must talk and get to know the why behind the attitude, before I can truly change the thinking.